These honors are different than the NCAA All American awards, which are based on finish at Nationals.
| Vault | ||
| All America | Ashleigh Gnat | LSU |
| All America | AJ Jackson | Oklahoma |
| All America | Olivia Karas | Michigan |
| All America | Brandie Jay | Georgia |
| All America | Brittany Rogers | Georgia |
| All America | Elizabeth Price | Stanford |
| All America | Kennedy Baker | Florida |
| All America | Alex McMurtry | Florida |
| 2nd Team All America | Alicia Boren | Florida |
| 2nd Team All America | Sydney Ewing | LSU |
| 2nd Team All America | Lauren Beers | Alabama |
| 2nd Team All America | Amanda Wellick | Arkansas |
| 2nd Team All America | Kirah Koshinski | West Virginia |
| 2nd Team All America | Breanna Hughes | Utah |
| 2nd Team All America | Bridget Sloan | Florida |
| 2nd Team All America | Nina McGee | Denver |
| 2nd Team All America | Caitlin Atkinson | Auburn |
| Uneven Bars | ||
| All America | Krystine Jacobsen | Boise State |
| All America | McKenzie Wofford | Oklahoma |
| All America | Bridget Sloan | Florida |
| All America | Alex McMurtry | Florida |
| All America | Elizabeth Price | Stanford |
| All America | Keeley Kmieciak | Oklahoma |
| All America | Kaytianna McMillan | Oregon State |
| All America | Brittany Rogers | Georgia |
| All America | Chayse Capps | Oklahoma |
| All America | Kiana Winston | Alabama |
| 2nd Team All America | Sarah Finnegan | LSU |
| 2nd Team All America | Nicole Lehrmann | Oklahoma |
| 2nd Team All America | Kiera Brown | Penn State |
| 2nd Team All America | Bridgette Caquatto | Florida |
| 2nd Team All America | Breanna Hughes | Utah |
| 2nd Team All America | Nina McGee | Denver |
| Balance Beam | ||
| All America | Chayse Capps | Oklahoma |
| All America | Danusia Francis | UCLA |
| All America | Alex McMurtry | florida |
| All America | Sarah Finnegan | LSU |
| All America | Sunny Kato | Illinois-Champaign |
| All America | Aja Sims | Alabama |
| All America | Bridget Sloan | Florida |
| All America | Nicole Artz | Michigan |
| All America | Natalie Brown | Oklahoma |
| All America | Lindsay Mable | Minnesota |
| All America | Caitlin Atkinson | Auburn |
| 2nd Team All America | Hanna Nordquist | Minnesota |
| 2nd Team All America | Mary Beth Box | Georgia |
| 2nd Team All America | Madeline Gardiner | Oregon State |
| 2nd Team All America | Maddy Stover | Utah |
| 2nd Team All America | Britney Ward | Missouri |
| Floor Exercise | ||
| All America | Ashleigh Gnat | LSU |
| All America | Nina McGee | Denver |
| All America | Nicole Artz | Michigan |
| All America | Bridget Sloan | Florida |
| All America | Haley Scaman | Oklahoma |
| All America | Kennedy Baker | Florida |
| All America | Olivia Karas | Michigan |
| All America | Lindsay Mable | Minnesota |
| All America | Toni-Ann Williams | California |
| All America | Sadiqua Bynum | UCLA |
| 2nd Team All America | Angi Cipra | UCLA |
| 2nd Team All America | Sandra Collantes | Boise State |
| 2nd Team All America | Caitlin Atkinson | Auburn |
| 2nd Team All America | Maddie Krentz | Boise State |
| 2nd Team All America | Mary Beth Box | Georgia |
| 2nd Team All America | Breanna Hughes | Utah |
| All Around | ||
| All America | Bridget Sloan | Florida |
| All America | Chayse Capps | Oklahoma |
| All America | Kennedy Baker | Florida |
| All America | Nina McGee | Denver |
| All America | Caitlin Atkinson | Auburn |
| All America | Elizabeth Price | Stanford |
| All America | Breanna Hughes | Utah |
| All America | Lindsay Mable | Minnesota |
| 2nd Team All America | Brandie Jay | Georgia |
| 2nd Team All America | Olivia Karas | Michigan |
| 2nd Team All America | Alicia Boren | Florida |
| 2nd Team All America | Nicole Artz | Michigan |
| 2nd Team All America | Myia Hambrick | LSU |
| 2nd Team All America | Keeley Kmieciak | Oklahoma |
| 2nd Team All America | Allison Northey | Washington |
| 2nd Team All America | Hollie Blanske | Nebraska |
Link: NACGC/W List